Travis Shaw more of a utility guy now

RIP Travis Shaw’s dreams of being the Boston Red Sox everyday third baseman.

It was going well until about late May — and then he hit .205 with a .632 OPS from May 29 to August 31. Call a Mr. Yoan Moncada to the stage.

Yeah, so the young Moncada is pretty much the Red Sox new starting third baseman. He’s an upgrade over Shaw — hopefully — but yesterday, there was a clear indication Shaw is moving into more of a Brock Holt type role. Why else would he have been playing the outfield Monday?

Seriously: if Shaw were a third baseman, he would have been playing third base — especially against a subpar right-handed pitcher in Edwin Jackson. But no, he was in the outfield — because Chris Young isn’t fantastic against righties. But he did have that pinch-hit homer off a lefty reliever (which was pretty sweet if I could say so myself).

Looking at next year, it would be tough to justify starting Travis Shaw and expecting to have some sort of world-class lineup. Yes, David Ortiz being gone opens up the opportunity. But can you really replace one of the greatest hitters in Red Sox history with a guy who is hovering the Mendoza Line (.200) since late May? No way, Jose.

If Shaw is going to make the team next year — which up for debate with the almighty Pablo Sandoval returning in 2017 and the second coming of Wade Boggs (Moncada)  also fighting for the third base job — it would probably be as a utility guy — like Tim “The Toolman” Taylor.

Think about it: he’s a left-handed bat. He’s better against righties — 75 percent of pitching. So 75 percent of the team, he can enter the lineup at three positions. And he has a little pop. That’s kind of valuable good for a bench player. So what if his batting average is low? He was never really a top prospect and left-handed pop off the bench isn’t bad to have.

If nothing changes headed into next year, the Red Sox bench would probably be: Shaw, Holt, Young and Christian Vazquez. Yes, they have plenty more options (Marco Hernandez, Bryce Brentz, Bryan Holaday, Josh Rutledge and Blake Swihart among others), but that seems most likely.

Back to blog