Every November, New England gets to brag a little: the First Thanksgiving happened right here, in Plymouth, Massachusetts, in 1621. But a lot of what we learned with construction-paper pilgrim hats in second grade is, well, not quite right. Here are the First Thanksgiving facts versus the myths, from buckles to Plymouth Rock to who actually showed up for dinner.
We've already covered fun facts about Massachusetts and weird laws in Massachusetts, so grab a plate of leftovers. This one's pure Bay State history.
1. Myth: They Called It "Thanksgiving"
Fact: Nobody in 1621 called that harvest feast "Thanksgiving." To the Pilgrims, a day of thanksgiving was a religious day of prayer, and often fasting, not a three-day party. The 1621 get-together was a harvest celebration. The name got stuck on it much later, once Thanksgiving became a national holiday and people went looking for its origin story.
2. Myth: We Know Exactly What Happened
Fact: Almost everything we know about the 1621 feast comes from one short letter. Edward Winslow, one of the colonists, wrote it in December 1621, and it was published in London the next year in a pamphlet now known as Mourt's Relation. It's only a few sentences long. He wrote that the governor sent four men "fowling," that the Wampanoag leader Massasoit came with about ninety men, and that "for three days we entertained and feasted." That's basically the whole primary source. Everything else is educated guessing.
3. Myth: The Pilgrims Invited the Wampanoag
Fact: Winslow's letter doesn't say anyone was invited. Massasoit and his men showed up, and historians still debate why. One popular theory is that the colonists were firing guns while hunting or celebrating, and the Wampanoag came to check it out, since the two sides had signed a mutual-defense alliance that spring. However it started, the Wampanoag guests outnumbered the English roughly two to one.
4. Myth: Turkey Was the Star of the Table
Fact: Maybe, maybe not. Winslow only says "fowl," which could mean ducks, geese, or wild turkey. William Bradford's history of the colony does mention wild turkeys that fall, so turkey is possible. What we know for sure: the Wampanoag went out and killed five deer and brought them as their contribution, so venison was definitely on the menu. Corn was there too, likely as bread or porridge, and seafood like mussels, lobster, and eels was all over the area.
5. Myth: There Was Pumpkin Pie, Mashed Potatoes, and Cranberry Sauce
Fact: Sorry to the pie people. The colonists didn't have butter or wheat flour for crust, they didn't have an oven to bake in, and sugar was scarce, so no pumpkin pie and probably no sweet cranberry sauce either. Pumpkins and squash may have been around, just not in pie form. Potatoes weren't part of the New England diet yet. Your modern Thanksgiving plate is mostly a 1800s and 1900s invention, and honestly, we're not complaining.
6. Myth: Pilgrims Wore All Black With Buckles on Their Hats
Fact: The buckle look comes from 1800s artists, not the 1620s. Buckles didn't become fashionable until later in the 1600s. And the Pilgrims weren't dressed like funeral directors, either. Black was for Sunday best, but everyday clothes came in colors like brown, green, red, and violet, and estate records from Plymouth list some surprisingly colorful wardrobes. So the construction-paper hat with the big gold buckle? Pure fan fiction.
7. Myth: The Pilgrims Landed at Plymouth Rock
Fact: The Mayflower actually landed first at the tip of Cape Cod in November 1620, in what's now Provincetown. That's where the Mayflower Compact was signed. The colonists spent weeks exploring before settling at Plymouth in late December. As for Plymouth Rock, no one at the time ever mentioned it. It was identified as the landing spot in 1741, more than 120 years later, by a 94-year-old church elder named Thomas Faunce. Today it sits under a granite portico on the Plymouth waterfront, and yes, it's smaller than you're picturing. Every local who has ever visited has the same reaction, which is exactly why the Oh Cool A Rock Plymouth MA T-Shirt exists.
8. Myth: The Wampanoag Were Strangers Who Just Showed Up to Help
Fact: The Wampanoag had lived in what's now southeastern Massachusetts and Rhode Island for thousands of years, and the story is a lot more complicated than the storybook version. Plymouth was built on the site of Patuxet, a village emptied by an epidemic a few years before the Mayflower arrived. Tisquantum, better known as Squanto, was from Patuxet. He'd been kidnapped by an English captain in 1614 and sold into slavery in Spain, made his way to England, and came home in 1619 to find his village gone. He spoke English, which is why he ended up as an interpreter for the colonists, and he helped teach them to grow corn.
9. Myth: Thanksgiving Has Been a Holiday Since 1621
Fact: Not even close. Days of thanksgiving came and went for centuries, and George Washington proclaimed one in 1789, but there was no yearly national holiday. That changed thanks to a Granite Stater: Sarah Josepha Hale, born in Newport, New Hampshire, editor of Godey's Lady's Book, and the author of "Mary Had a Little Lamb." She lobbied presidents for about 17 years until Abraham Lincoln proclaimed a national Thanksgiving in 1863, in the middle of the Civil War. Then in 1939, Franklin Roosevelt moved it up a week to give holiday shopping a boost, people called it "Franksgiving," and Congress finally locked in the fourth Thursday of November in 1941.
10. Myth: Everyone Celebrates the Day the Same Way
Fact: Not everyone in New England treats Thanksgiving as a celebration. Since 1970, the United American Indians of New England have held a National Day of Mourning on Cole's Hill in Plymouth, overlooking Plymouth Rock, to remember the Native people who lost their lives and land after colonization. It's part of the real story too, and a good reminder that the "First Thanksgiving" is one moment in a much longer history. If you visit Plymouth, Plimoth Patuxet Museums does a good job telling both the English and Wampanoag sides.
However your family does it, with turkey, with lasagna, with a Patriots game on in the background and an uncle asleep in the recliner, we hope you've got a full table. Show up to dinner in the Wicked Thankful Turkey Label T-Shirt and you'll be the best-dressed history buff there.
Want more holiday reading? Check out In New England We Love Turkey, Football & Pie or plan a trip with Celebrate Thanksgiving in America's Hometown.
Know a Thanksgiving myth we missed? Tell us. We're New Englanders, and we love to argue about history over pie.
Born in New England. Fueled by iced coffee. Wicked proud of it since 2004.