The Chowdaheadz Times Back to The Times

Wicked Local: A New England Blog

New England Myths & Legends: The Dover Demon of Dover, Massachusetts

1977-style Polaroid of the Dover Demon on a stone wall with glowing orange eyes

If you've ever Googled the Dover Demon, you've seen the sketch: a bald, spindly little guy with a watermelon head and two glowing orange eyes, perched on a stone wall like he pays property taxes there. It's one of the most famous New England myths and legends, and it started on two April nights in 1977, about fifteen miles southwest of Boston, in the town of Dover, Massachusetts. Here's the townie version of what four teenagers said they saw, who investigated, and what the skeptics think it really was.

1. Where and When It Happened

Dover is a quiet, leafy, stone-wall-and-horse-fence kind of town. On the nights of April 21 and 22, 1977, three separate sightings were reported by teenagers who, as far as anyone has been able to tell, didn't compare notes first. The roads involved were Farm Street, Miller Hill Road, and Springdale Avenue. No cell phones, no group chat, no TikTok. Just a spring night and a spooky wall.

2. Night One: Bill Bartlett on Farm Street

Around 10:30 p.m. on April 21, seventeen-year-old Bill Bartlett was driving north on Farm Street with two friends. His headlights hit a low wall of loose stones, and something was crawling on it. He figured it was a dog or a cat. Then it turned its head. Bartlett described a huge, oval head on a thin neck, glowing orange eyes "like marbles," spindly arms and legs, long fingers curled around the rocks, and rough, peach-colored hairless skin. It stood roughly three and a half to four feet tall. His friends didn't see it. Shaken, Bartlett went home and drew it, and wrote on the sketch that he'd swear he saw it on a stack of Bibles.

3. Two Hours Later: John Baxter on Miller Hill Road

About two hours after that, fifteen-year-old John Baxter was walking home along Miller Hill Road when he saw a short figure coming toward him. He assumed it was a friend, called out, and got no answer. It ran off the road and down into a wooded gully, where Baxter said he saw it standing on a rock, gripping a tree, about thirty feet away. He described a monkey-like body and a strange, dark head. Baxter said he hadn't heard about Bartlett's sighting, yet his drawing looked a lot like Bartlett's.

4. Night Two: Abby Brabham and Will Taintor

Near midnight the next night, eighteen-year-old Will Taintor was driving fifteen-year-old Abby Brabham home on Springdale Avenue when she spotted a thin, hairless creature crouched at the roadside. She described a big, oblong head with no visible nose, ears, or mouth, tan skin, and glowing eyes. One difference: she insisted the eyes were green, not orange, even when investigators later told her what Bartlett had said. Taintor only caught a quick glimpse.

5. Who Named It and Who Investigated

The teens didn't call the cops or the newspaper. The story spread by word of mouth until cryptozoologist Loren Coleman, who lived nearby, heard it on April 28 at the Dover Country Store. He interviewed the witnesses and brought in UFO researchers Walter Webb, Joseph Nyman, and Ed Fogg. They talked to parents, a principal, and a science teacher. Their conclusion at the time: the kids seemed honest, and a hoax was possible but unlikely. The Dover police chief, meanwhile, told the Associated Press in May 1977 that it was probably a school vacation prank. Classic.

6. What Did It Look Like? The Greatest Hits

Pull the descriptions together and you get a consistent little monster:

  • About 3½ to 4 feet tall
  • Thin limbs, big hands and feet
  • Hairless skin, peach or tan
  • A huge, oval, melon-shaped head
  • Large glowing eyes (orange or green, depending on who you ask)
  • No obvious nose or mouth

Honestly, it sounds like a Boston winter after the third nor'easter in a row.

7. Theory: A Snowy Owl

In 2023, skeptical investigator Joe Nickell proposed that the creature was a male snowy owl. A white owl on a wall would bounce back headlights, its big round head and eyes fit the drawings, and spread wings could read as long, skinny arms. It's a neat idea. It also asks a lot of one owl on two nights in three places.

8. Theory: A Foal, a Moose Calf, or a Hoax

Others have suggested a baby horse or moose calf glimpsed in the dark, though critics say neither looks much like the sketches. Skeptoid's Brian Dunning argued in 2024 that a teenage hoax is the only explanation without a major hole, while being careful to say he wasn't accusing anyone of lying. And no, Close Encounters of the Third Kind can't take the blame. It came out eight months after the sightings. The truth is that no physical evidence was ever found, and nobody has seen the thing since.

9. Bill Bartlett, the Artist

Bartlett grew up to be a professional artist, and by most accounts his story has never changed. He reportedly gets tired of telling it, especially around Halloween and the April anniversary. Dover has made peace with its monster too: the Dover Historical Society has sold T-shirts with a cartoon of the creature and the question, "Dover Demon, do you believe?" We say wear the shirt, skip the wall.

10. Rep the Hub (and the Legends)

Whether the Dover Demon was an owl, a prank, or something with no name, it's pure Massachusetts: a stone wall, a late-night drive, and a story nobody can shut up about nearly fifty years later. If you want to wear your Bay State pride while you keep one eye on the stonewalls, try the Boston Monstah T-Shirt for the monster-sized accent, or the Wicked Crabby T-Shirt for how you'll feel after a demon spoils your drive home.

Want more New England spooky stuff? Read The Bridgewater Triangle, The Gloucester Sea Serpent, The Lady in Black of Fort Warren, or Fun Facts About Massachusetts.

Did you grow up near Dover, or have your own wall story? Tell us. We're New Englanders. We believe you (mostly).

Born in New England. Fueled by iced coffee. Wicked proud of it since 2004.